9. Regardtng the st·cond reason g1vcn by the Court (the conlinuallon of
tht~
alleged violations), Lhe Court oughl to have examined these allegations more
closclv and possibly estabhsh a distinction between Lhc "mstantaneous" and
the "continuous" facts, as 1t approprintelv did an another JUdgment delivered on
m~lter
the !iamc day, in the
or
the Benejic1anes of late Norbert Zongo and al. u.
Bttrkma Fasrrl. ll should have ask<'d itself whether U1c alleged violation ol
ArL.icle 15 of lhe Charter (lhe dtsmtssal of Lhe Applicant by U1e UniversH\> of
nol an "'mstant.ancous'' fact outside the ratione tempons
jurisdiction of the Court, and whether on the conlrcuy lhe alleged vtoli::ll10n of
Malawi) was
Article 7 of the Cht=trlcr (the mannt•r in which the JocaJ Courls handled lhe
maller) was
not a
"continunu::;" fact,
jurisdiction. An indepth
analy~1s
wh1eh falls within its temporal
of these 1ssues would have enabled the Court
ro arrive at a more informed conclu:-;ion w1lh regard lo
ILS
JUrsdiction ratione
temp oris.
l 0. In our opinion, the:: Court therefore missed an opportumty Lo make clear
jurisprudence on nn issue which will likely resurface
tn
the future.
m. The issue of exhaustion of local remedies
ll. The most serious problem raised by lhe judgment of the Court however 1s
its approach and dectston on the question of exhaustion of local remedtes. After
a summary of how Lhc various local Courts handled lhe matter
occasions
!paragraph~
011
several
21 lo 28 and 39), the Court roncludes in substance lhal
the Appllcanl did not exhaust local rcrncdies 1 because he dirl nol argue the
appeal wh1ch he had brought before lhc High Court agamsl a decision of the
Industrial
Relauon~
Court, and that under such conditions. he could not go to
the Supreme Court of Appeal if he wr.rc not to be satisfied with the dt!dsion of
the Hjgh Court regarding h1s claims for reparation for unlawfuJ dismissal
(paragrapla 40.1 ).
1
The :!1 Jurw 20l:JjudgrnN1t J)rtrngmph tl:l,
4
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents