F.
Alleged violation of Articles 17(2) and (3) of the Charter
Applicant's Submission
170.
The Applicant, citing its own jurisprudence in the Endorois Case avers that
"Culture could be taken to mean that complex whole which includes a spiritual and
physical association with one's ancestral land , knowledge , belief, art, law, morals,
customs and any other capabilities and habits acquired by humankind as a
member of society - the sum total of the material and spiritual activities and
products of a given socia l group that distinguish it from other similar groups and in
that
it
encompasses
a
group's
religion ,
language,
and
other
defining
characteristics". On the basis of this , the Applicant submits that the cultural rights
of the Ogieks have been violated by the Respondent, through restrictions on
access to the Mau forest which hosts their cu ltural sites. According to the Applicant,
their attempts to access their historic lands for cu ltu ra l purposes have been met
with intimidation and detention, and serious restrictions have been imposed by the
Kenyan authorities on their hunter-gatherer way of life, after the Respondent
forcefully evicted them from the Mau Forest.
171.
The App licant maintains that the Ogieks should be allowed to determine
what culture is good for them rather than the Respondent doing so. The
Applicant calls on the Court to be inspired by Article 61 of the Charter and
urges the Court to find that the Respondent is in violation of Article 17 of the Charter in respect
of the Ogieks and prays the Court to issue an Order for reparation.
172.
While testifying about the cultural evolution of the Ogieks, the expert witness
maintains and reiterates her earlier position as elaborated in the section on religion
above in paragraph 161 .
Respondent's Submission
173. The Respondent argues that it recognises and affirms the provisions of Article
17 of the Charter and has taken reasonable steps both at the national and
international levels to ensure that the cu ltural rights of indigenous peoples in Kenya
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents