The Court composed of: Augustine S. L. RAMADHANI; President, Elsie N. THOMPSON, Vice-President; Gerard NIYUNGEKO, Fatsah OUGUERGOUZ, Duncan TAMBALA, Sylvain ORE, El Hadji GUISSE, Ben KIOKO, Rania BEN ACHOUR, Solomy B. BOSSA, Angelo V. MATUSSE- Judges; and Robert ENO- Registrar. In the matter of: lngabire Victoire UMUHOZA represented by: i. Mr. Gatera GASHABANA- Counsel ii. Dr. Caroline BUISMAN- Counsel V. The Republic of Rwanda represented by: Mr. Rubango Kayihura EPIMAQUE, Senior State Attorney, Republic of Rwanda. After deliberation, delivers the following Ruling: 1

Select target paragraph3